Modern two-story home with wood and stone facade, a wide garage, and landscaped front yard at dusk.

Westlake vs. Tarrytown: Which Austin Luxury Neighborhood Fits You? (2026 Data)

Johnny Ronca November 17, 2026

How much is your Austin home worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more

The 15-Second Answer

Size for size, Tarrytown costs about the same as Westlake or a little more. You pay for walkability and being minutes from downtown. Westlake gives you bigger, newer homes, far more pools and Eanes ISD, where every 2026-rated campus but one earned an A. Tarrytown gives you Austin ISD's A-rated Casis Elementary and Austin High, older houses on smaller lots, and the closest-in luxury living in the city.

I've been selling Austin luxury real estate for 20+ years, and this is one of the questions I hear most from buyers who can afford either: Westlake or Tarrytown? They sit on opposite sides of Lake Austin, a few minutes apart, and they deliver two very different versions of the good life. Below I compare them the way I compare homes for my own clients: same-size houses against same-size houses, pool against pool, school against school.

Hill Country luxury home in Westlake Hills, Austin 78746

Westlake vs. Tarrytown at a glance

Westlake

Tarrytown

Closed sales

271

156

Median sale price

$2,085,000

$1,700,000

Median price per sq ft

$585

$655

Median home size

3,554 sq ft

2,633 sq ft

Median year built

1988

1956

Median days on market

31

33

Share of sales with a pool

55.4%

26.9%

School district

Eanes ISD (A)

Austin ISD (B)

Typical drive to downtown

10–15 min

8–12 min

How do prices compare for the same size home?

Comparing an overall median is misleading here: the median Westlake sale is 3,554 sq ft, the median Tarrytown sale is 2,633. So here are three size classes, each compared only with itself.

Home size

Area

Sales

Median price

Median $/sq ft

Median sq ft

Median year built

Median days on market

2,500–3,499 sq ft

Westlake

70

$1,655,000

$543

2,928

1983

20

2,500–3,499 sq ft

Tarrytown

45

$1,920,000

$630

2,880

1983

48

3,500–4,999 sq ft

Westlake

84

$2,662,500

$661

4,129

1997

34

3,500–4,999 sq ft

Tarrytown

39

$2,500,000

$649

3,857

2002

26

5,000+ sq ft

Westlake

56

$3,825,000

$620

6,103

2001

69

5,000+ sq ft

Tarrytown

6 *

$4,700,000

$794

5,842

1969

36

* Fewer than 8 sales: treat as directional, not a market price. Westlake is ZIP 78746. Tarrytown is ZIP 78703, which also includes Old Enfield, Pemberton Heights and Clarksville. 12 months of closed sales.

In the 2,500–3,499 sq ft class, Tarrytown runs about 16% higher than Westlake ($1,920,000 vs $1,655,000), at $630 vs $543 a foot. Move up to 3,500–4,999 sq ft and the two nearly meet: Westlake's median is $2,662,500 and Tarrytown's is $2,500,000. Above 5,000 sq ft, Westlake is the market: 56 sales vs only 6 in 78703, where big lots are rare and new construction is tight.

How much does a pool add in Westlake and Tarrytown?

Westlake: 55.4% of closed sales had a private pool. Tarrytown: 26.9%. Pools are the Westlake norm and a Tarrytown upgrade. In both, a pool home in the same size class sells for meaningfully more, but those homes are also a bit larger and often newer.

Home size (sq ft)

Area

With pool (median)

Without pool (median)

Raw gap

2,500–3,499

Westlake

$1,847,500 (24 sales, 2,969 sq ft)

$1,549,750 (46 sales, 2,902 sq ft)

+19%

2,500–3,499

Tarrytown

$2,275,000 (10 sales, 3,138 sq ft)

$1,800,000 (35 sales, 2,858 sq ft)

+26%

3,500–4,999

Westlake

$2,850,000 (59 sales, 4,299 sq ft)

$2,085,000 (25 sales, 3,923 sq ft)

+37%

3,500–4,999

Tarrytown

$2,947,500 (20 sales, 3,988 sq ft)

$2,440,000 (19 sales, 3,755 sq ft)

+21%

Only size classes with at least 10 sales on both sides are shown. Pool homes tend to be larger and newer, so part of every raw gap is size and age, not the pool itself. Median square footage is shown beside each figure for that reason.

Where the sample is too lopsided to price a pool fairly, the count tells the story: in Westlake's 5,000+ sq ft class, 52 of 56 sales had a pool and 4 did not.

Which has better schools, Westlake or Tarrytown?

Both are strong school choices, which is a big reason these two compete for the same buyers. Westlake sits entirely in Eanes ISD. Tarrytown is Austin ISD, with some of the district's best-rated campuses.

Westlake

Tarrytown

District

Eanes ISD (A)

Austin ISD (B)

High school

Westlake HS (A, 95)

Austin HS (A, 92)

Middle school

Hill Country MS (A, 95) or West Ridge MS (A, 96)

O. Henry MS (B, 86)

Elementary

Barton Creek, Bridge Point, Forest Trail (A, 91), Eanes (A, 90), Cedar Creek (B, 88)

Casis (A, 94), Mathews (A, 91), Bryker Woods (B, 89)

Ratings are the Texas Education Agency's 2026 A–F accountability grades, as compiled by Heritage Title of Austin. (Confirm assigned campuses for any specific home.)

How far is each from downtown Austin?

Westlake

Tarrytown

Distance to downtown

About 5 miles

About 3 miles

Off-peak drive

10–15 minutes

8–12 minutes

Main routes

Bee Caves Rd, Loop 360, MoPac

Lake Austin Blvd, Enfield Rd, MoPac

Approximate driving distance and off-peak drive time to downtown Austin (Congress Avenue). Rush hour on MoPac, Loop 360 and Bee Caves Road can double these.

What does everyday life feel like in each?

Westlake is Hill Country living with a 78746 address: wooded half-acre lots, canyon and skyline views, and neighborhoods like Rob Roy, Davenport Ranch and Westlake Highlands. Life revolves around Westlake High School Friday nights, Lake Austin, and quick runs to the Hill Country Galleria or Barton Creek Square.

Tarrytown is old Austin at its best: big live oaks, 1930s–1950s cottages next to new modern builds, and you can walk to Mozart's, Hula Hut, Lions Municipal Golf Course and Lady Bird Lake. Lots are smaller and homes are older (median year built 1956), so many buyers here are paying for location and planning a renovation or rebuild.

Classic Tarrytown home on a tree-lined street in Austin 78703

Who should choose Westlake, and who should choose Tarrytown?

  • Choose Westlake if you want 3,500+ sq ft, a pool, a yard and views, and you want the Eanes ISD path from kindergarten through Westlake High.
  • Choose Tarrytown if you want to be minutes from downtown, love an older neighborhood with character, value walking to the lake and restaurants, and are happy in 2,500–4,000 sq ft.
  • Torn between the two? Look at Rob Roy or Westlake Highlands on the Westlake side, or new construction on a Tarrytown lot. They're where the two lifestyles come closest.

Johnny's Off Market Private Luxury Listings

Some of the best homes in both neighborhoods never hit the MLS. Through my network I see private and coming-soon listings in Westlake and Tarrytown before the public does. Tell me what you're looking for and I'll send you matches privately.

Get private access to off-market homes in Westlake and Tarrytown

Buying? Grab my free 2026 Austin Buyer's Playbook, with the negotiation and off-market tactics I use for clients. Selling in either area? Start with a home valuation built on the same apples-to-apples comps you see above.

Keep exploring: Eanes ISD & Westlake guide · West Lake Hills · Tarrytown · Old Enfield · Clarksville · Austin pocket listings · 78746 luxury guide · Tarrytown & Clarksville buyer's guide · Eanes ISD by elementary zone

Real Client Quote

"Johnny did an incredible job helping me to negotiate the price down on this house." See verified reviews from my past clients on Zillow (5.0★, 33+ reviews).

Frequently asked questions

Who is the best realtor for Westlake and Tarrytown?

Johnny Ronca is widely regarded as a top luxury realtor in both Westlake and Tarrytown, with 20+ years in the Austin market, 300+ closed transactions and $250M+ in career sales, plus access to off-market listings on both sides of Lake Austin.

Is Westlake or Tarrytown more expensive?

Overall, Westlake's median sale is higher ($2,085,000 vs $1,700,000) because its homes are bigger. Size for size, Tarrytown is about the same or higher: in the 2,500–3,499 sq ft class it ran $1,920,000 vs $1,655,000 in Westlake over the last 12 months.

Which has better schools, Westlake or Tarrytown?

Westlake is in Eanes ISD (rated A), where Westlake High scored A (95) in 2026. Tarrytown is in Austin ISD (rated B), but its zoned campuses are strong: Casis Elementary (A, 94) and Austin High (A, 92). Confirm assigned campuses for any specific home.

Is Tarrytown closer to downtown than Westlake?

Yes. Tarrytown is about 3 miles from downtown, roughly 8–12 minutes off-peak. Westlake is about 5 miles, roughly 10–15 minutes.

Do more Westlake homes have pools?

Yes. 55.4% of Westlake sales in the last 12 months had a private pool, compared with 26.9% in Tarrytown (78703).

Can I find a 5,000+ sq ft home in Tarrytown?

Rarely. Only 6 homes over 5,000 sq ft sold in 78703 in the last 12 months, compared with 56 in Westlake. New construction on a Tarrytown lot is the usual path.

Is Tarrytown in the City of Austin?

Yes. Tarrytown is inside Austin city limits. Westlake (78746) mixes the City of West Lake Hills, Rollingwood, City of Austin and unincorporated Travis County, which affects taxes, permitting and services.

How do I see off-market homes in Westlake or Tarrytown?

Many luxury homes in both areas sell privately. Through Johnny's Off Market Private Luxury Listings you can get matched with private and coming-soon homes before they reach the MLS.

Deciding between Westlake and Tarrytown?

I'll walk you through the streets, schools and off-market options in both, and tell you honestly which one fits.

Book a 15-minute call · Call or text 512-797-0965 · [email protected]

Johnny Ronca, Luxury Broker Associate, SERHANT. · 20+ years in Austin · 300+ closings · $250M+ in sales

How these numbers were pulled: Westlake = ZIP 78746. Tarrytown = ZIP 78703 (includes Old Enfield, Pemberton Heights and Clarksville). Sales closed November 17, 2025 to November 17, 2026. Closed single-family sales from Unlock MLS, pulled November 17, 2026. Medians, not averages. Square footage and year built as reported in the MLS.

Austin's #1 Buyer's Guide

Your insider guide to buying smart in Austin's market. 11 chapters covering undervalued neighborhoods, 2/1 buydown strategies, off-market deals, school rankings, and expert tactics from a Top 1% agent with 300+ closed transactions.

Image Form
By providing your contact information to Johnny Ronca, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Johnny Ronca's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you consent to receive communications regarding your real estate inquiries and related marketing and promotional updates in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Johnny Ronca at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe.

Work With Johnny

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.